I was watching Paul Bremer on Charlie Rose last night, and Rose asked if Bremer would have had an easier time of administering Iraq if he'd been an expert on Iraq, or an Arabist. To quote Bremer's response as accurately as I can, "Sure, it would have made it easier. But it would've made it harder in some ways, too: a lot of the experts were skeptical about our ability to succeed [in establishing a stable democracy] over there."
That, ladies and gentlemen, is exactly what's wrong with Bush, his administration, the Republican Party, and the persons who vote for its candidates: a profound, almost pathological anti-intellectualism.
I mean, if experts are warning you against a given action in a field in which they are expert,
shouldn't you listen to them? You can read my thoughts on the probability of success in our current efforts in Iraq
here. With all due respect to Mr. Bremer, with my MA in History, I know a
hell of a lot more about the history of foreign interventions in West Asia than he or, it would seem, just about anybody making actual decisions about our policy in Iraq. And I'm hardly an expert.
Pick any complex issue, and you'll find that the Republicans (of whom I have a frighteningly representative microcosm in my parents) are likely rejecting the word of academicians and other denizens of the Ivory Tower in favor of "common sense" or some other rubbish. Iraq? Case in point. Intelligent Design? Well, how
could somebody who is knowledgeable about the world's organisms be objective about creationism? Global Warming? Climatologists are all biased.
Hey, does anybody remember
V, when the aliens took steps to discredit scientists, who then would not be believed when they presented evidence of the aliens' true form and plans? I'm just sayin'.
Knowledge creates an inherent bias against actions or opinions that knowledge demonstrates to be wrong. I personally am biased against divine intervention, spontaneous generation, Lamarckian evolution, phrenology, and, of course, having faith in those in power. No wonder Bush doesn't like academicians.
Yes, all you academicians who voted to reelect Bush are
fools. Go ahead, comment on this post; you know you want to.